If you think Kentucky has the market cornered on great bourbon or Tennessee on whiskey, it’s time to look a little closer to home. Right here in the Hoosier State, craft distillers are producing some of the finest spirits from Indiana — and many of them are flying under the radar.
At Payless Liquors, we love celebrating local talent. So today, we’re shining a spotlight on small-batch spirits from Indiana that deserve a spot in your home bar. Whether you’re a whiskey lover, vodka enthusiast, or looking to explore something new, these hidden gems deliver quality with a local touch.
1. Hard Truth Distilling Co. — Brown County, IN
Tucked away in scenic Brown County, Hard Truth Distilling is quickly becoming a go-to name for craft spirits from Indiana. Their sweet mash rye whiskey has earned national awards, but locals know their cinnamon vodka and toasted coconut rum are perfect for cocktails year-round. Try their Straight Rye Whiskey neat — it’s bold, spicy, and 100% Indiana-made.
2. Hotel Tango Distillery — Indianapolis, IN
As the first combat-disabled veteran-owned distillery in the U.S., Hotel Tango brings a unique edge to the Indiana spirits scene. Their versatile line includes bourbon, gin, and even ready-to-drink cocktails. Their Victor Vodka and Golf Gin are smooth, crisp, and great for upgrading your classic drinks while supporting a local veteran-owned business.
3. Cardinal Spirits — Bloomington, IN
Cardinal Spirits is a craft distillery that puts Bloomington on the map for more than just college basketball. Their Bramble black raspberry liqueur and Terra Botanical Gin offer a fresh take on traditional spirits from Indiana. Don’t miss their Straight Bourbon Whiskey — a small-batch release with rich caramel and vanilla notes.
4. Starlight Distillery — Borden, IN
Located on a family farm, Starlight Distillery produces handcrafted spirits from Indiana with a focus on bourbon and brandy. Their Carl T. Bourbon is a fan favorite at Payless Liquors, offering smooth oak and dark fruit flavors. It’s perfect for sipping or gifting to the whiskey lover in your life.
5. Oakley Brothers Distillery — Anderson, IN
One of Indiana’s best-kept secrets, Oakley Brothers Distillery crafts small-batch spirits that capture the essence of Hoosier craftsmanship. Their rye whiskey and honey liqueur bring unique flavors to your glass, perfect for those looking to try something new and truly local.
Why Choose Local Spirits from Indiana?
Choosing small-batch spirits from Indiana isn’t just about supporting local businesses — it’s about discovering authentic flavors and craftsmanship you won’t find in mass-produced bottles. Many of these distilleries use Indiana-grown grains, local botanicals, and time-honored techniques passed down through generations.
At Payless Liquors, we’re proud to stock a wide selection of Indiana spirits, from the well-known to the hidden gems. Next time you’re shopping for your home bar, ask our team for their local favorites — you might just find your new go-to bottle.
Ready to explore more? Visit your nearest Payless Liquors location and ask about our latest selection of Indiana-made spirits!
