Here’s our 2025 Father’s Day whiskey gift guide, curated with dads (and tastebuds) in mind. Father’s Day is around the corner, and if your dad loves a good pour, there’s no better gift than a thoughtfully selected bottle of whiskey. At Payless Liquors, Indiana’s go-to destination for top-shelf spirits, we’ve put together a list of the best whiskeys to celebrate Dad this year.

Whether he’s a bourbon enthusiast, a Scotch traditionalist, or just enjoys winding down with something smooth, we’ve got the perfect bottle for him.

1. Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon

Why Dad Will Love It: Elegant, complex, and highly sought after, Blanton’s delivers notes of caramel, orange peel, and a hint of spice.
Perfect For: The bourbon collector or the dad who appreciates something rare and refined.

2. Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon

Why Dad Will Love It: This well-balanced bourbon has warm spice, subtle smoke, and a smooth finish—ideal for sipping neat or on the rocks.
Perfect For: The dad who enjoys classic Kentucky craftsmanship at a great value.

3. Lagavulin 16 Year Old Scotch

Why Dad Will Love It: Bold, peaty, and full of character, this Islay Scotch is a flavor journey.
Perfect For: The dad who loves smoky, rich whiskies and complex flavor profiles.

4. Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon

Why Dad Will Love It: A true staple with notes of dried fruit, vanilla, and toasted oak. Smooth enough for new drinkers but complex enough for connoisseurs.
Perfect For: The well-rounded dad who appreciates both flavor and tradition.

5. Jameson Black Barrel Irish Whiskey

Why Dad Will Love It: Triple-distilled and twice-charred barrels give this whiskey a deeper, richer flavor than your standard Jameson.
Perfect For: The easygoing dad who loves a good Irish whiskey—especially one with a bit more depth.

6. Uncle Nearest 1856 Premium Whiskey

Why Dad Will Love It: Rich, full-bodied Tennessee whiskey with a compelling backstory and bold taste.
Perfect For: The dad who enjoys heritage brands and supporting Black-owned businesses in the whiskey world.

7. Smoke Wagon Small Batch Bourbon

Why Dad Will Love It: Hailing from Nevada but made with Midwest-aged bourbon, this bottle has a cult following for a reason—sweet, spicy, and smooth.
Perfect For: The adventurous dad who’s always looking for something new to try.

Still Not Sure Which Father’s Day Whiskey to Pick?

Every dad is different—and so is every bottle. Some prefer bold, smoky flavors with a long finish, while others enjoy a smoother, sweeter sip to wind down the day. If you’re unsure which father’s day whiskey best fits your father’s personality and palate, stop by any Payless Liquors location across Indiana. Our knowledgeable staff is here to guide you through the options, whether you’re looking for a rare collector’s bottle or a budget-friendly favorite with great flavor.

We’ll help you choose something that feels personal, thoughtful, and perfectly suited to your dad. Because at the end of the day, Father’s Day isn’t just about the gift—it’s about raising a glass to the man who’s always been there.

Pro Tip: Want to Make It Extra Special?

Pick up one of our Father’s Day gift sets, or ask our team about pairing your bottle with premium cigars, glassware, or accessories.

Visit Your Local Payless Liquors Today

From Indy to Avon to Greenwood and beyond, Payless Liquors stores across Indiana are stocked and ready with the best father’s day whiskey gifts for Dad. Can’t decide? Our staff is happy to help you find a bottle he’ll love.

Cheers to Dad – and great whiskey.

Shop in-store or call ahead for availability. Some limited-edition bottles may not be available at all locations.