There’s something special about being part of the Indiana sports fans. Whether you’re cheering from the nosebleeds, gathering around your living room TV, or tuning in from a tailgate, game day is a tradition—and it deserves a great drink in hand.
From buzzer-beaters to backyard watch parties, Payless Liquors has everything you need to keep your cup full and your spirit high. This guide is made just for Indiana sports fans looking to level up their drink game all season long.
Why Indiana Sports Fans Deserve a Signature Sip
Basketball isn’t just a game in Indiana—it’s a way of life. And for those who follow the action week after week, creating the perfect drink lineup is part of the ritual. Whether you’re all about local brews, small-batch bourbon, or easy cocktails, Payless Liquors has game night covered.
First Quarter Favorites: Easygoing Beers & Seltzers
Before the game heats up, start light. These drinks are sessionable, refreshing, and perfect for that first tip-off.
✅ Top Picks:
-
Sun King Cream Ale – A classic Indianapolis favorite. Smooth, crisp, and crowd-friendly.
-
3 Floyds Gumballhead – A zesty wheat beer with just enough attitude for game night.
-
High Noon Hard Seltzers – Clean, fruity, and ideal for keeping things light.
Pro Tip: Keep these chilled in a cooler by the TV—less running to the fridge, more cheering on your team.
Halftime Huddle: Bourbon Breaks & Themed Cocktails
The game’s tight, you’ve got your people gathered, and it’s time to make things interesting. Halftime is the perfect moment for a bold pour or a signature cocktail.
Indiana-Approved Bourbons:
-
Starlight Distillery Single Barrel Bourbon – Locally crafted and rich with flavor.
-
Woodford Reserve – A smooth, reliable go-to for bourbon lovers.
-
Old Forester 100 – Bold and budget-friendly for entertaining a group.
DIY Cocktail: “3-Point Punch”
-
1.5 oz bourbon
-
1 oz orange juice
-
1 oz cranberry juice
-
Splash of soda water
-
Garnish with an orange peel
Mix in a pitcher and serve in plastic cups for a game-day vibe.
Snack Pairings for Real Fans
Indiana sports fans don’t settle for chips and dip alone. Match your drinks with next-level snacks.
Pairing Ideas:
-
IPA + Nachos – Hoppy bitterness cuts through rich cheese.
-
Bourbon + BBQ Sliders – Sweet, smoky flavors bring out the best in each other.
-
Hard Seltzer + Popcorn – Light and crunchy to keep you sipping.
Final Buzzer Finishers: Celebrate or Commiserate
Whether your team brings it home or barely misses, the fourth quarter calls for something smooth and satisfying.
End-of-Game Pours:
-
Bailey’s Irish Cream over Ice – Dessert in a glass.
-
Buffalo Trace Bourbon – For fans who like a classic, warm finish.
-
Amaretto or Frangelico – Nutty liqueurs that are easy to sip late into the night.
Light up a firepit, throw on the post-game show, and enjoy the nightcap.
Hosting a Watch Party? Stock Up Smart
Hosting fellow Indiana sports fans? Make it easy and affordable to serve drinks for everyone.
Game Day Essentials:
-
Case of beer or variety seltzers
-
1-2 crowd-pleasing spirits (bourbon, vodka, rum)
-
Mixer pack: soda, tonic, ginger beer, juice
-
Ice, plastic cups, and cocktail napkins
-
Signature cocktail pitcher (like “3-Point Punch”)
Need help with quantities? Visit your local Payless Liquors and our team can guide you.
Bonus: Quick Tips for Hosting Indiana Sports Fans
-
Rep the Team Colors – Themed drinkware, napkins, or even drink garnishes (blue & gold, red & white, etc.)
-
Sound Up, Lights Down – Create an in-stadium vibe at home.
-
Friendly Wager Drinks – Loser buys the next round or mixes the cocktails!
Why Indiana Sports Fans Choose Payless Liquors
Payless Liquors has been Indiana’s go-to for beer, wine, and spirits for over 50 years. With multiple locations across the state, weekly specials, and knowledgeable staff, it’s the MVP when it comes to stocking up for any game.
Whether you’re celebrating a win or getting ready for the next tip-off, we’re here to help you drink like a true Indiana sports fan.
Final Word
Being an Indiana sports fan means heart, history, and high-fives. Make every game night memorable with the right drinks, easy recipes, and go-to favorites from Payless Liquors. Stock up, sip smart, and cheer loud.
See you on the couch—or courtside.
