Because life’s too short for bad tequila.

When most people think tequila, their minds go to lime wedges and party shots—but that’s just the beginning. Today’s premium tequilas are nuanced, handcrafted, and made for sipping, not slamming. Whether you’re a tequila connoisseur or just tequila-curious, investing in a high-end bottle can elevate your bar cart and your next gathering.

At Payless Liquors, we’ve got a hand-picked selection of premium tequilas that are absolutely worth the splurge. Here’s what makes them special—and why you should treat yourself (or someone else) to something truly exceptional.

1. Clase Azul Reposado

Smooth. Sweet. Iconic.
Housed in a hand-painted ceramic decanter, Clase Azul Reposado is as much a statement piece as it is a spirit. Made from 100% Blue Weber agave and aged for eight months in oak barrels, it delivers vanilla, hazelnut, and caramel notes that are dangerously easy to sip.

Why it’s worth it: Artisanal production + unbeatable smoothness + shelf appeal = totally gift-worthy.

2. Don Julio 1942

Luxury in a bottle.
You’ve seen it at high-end bars and on celebrity shelves for a reason. Don Julio 1942 is aged in American oak for at least two and a half years, resulting in a rich, velvety profile of toffee, oak, and roasted agave.

Why it’s worth it: Consistently ranked one of the best tequilas in the world—it’s a celebration in every pour.

3. Herradura Añejo

Rich, refined, and ready to impress.
Aged for 25 months in American white oak barrels—almost double the industry standard—Herradura Añejo delivers a beautifully smooth and complex profile. Expect notes of cooked agave, dried fruit, vanilla, and toasted oak with a long, luxurious finish.

Why it’s worth it: The aging process brings a deep, bourbon-like richness that makes this tequila perfect for sipping or slow-sipping Old Fashioneds.

4. Cincoro Reposado

Smooth, modern, and made by NBA legends.
Co-owned by Michael Jordan, Cincoro’s sleek bottle and luxury branding deliver—but the real star is what’s inside. Cincoro Reposado is aged 8–10 months and blends sweet vanilla and light oak with a hint of citrus.

Why it’s worth it: It’s the perfect balance of prestige and easy drinkability.

5. El Tesoro Extra Añejo

Aged to perfection.
Rested for four to five years in American oak, El Tesoro’s Extra Añejo develops deep, layered flavors of cocoa, dried fruit, and oak, while still honoring the agave-forward soul of traditional tequila.

Why it’s worth it: The craftsmanship and aging make this a tequila lover’s dream.

Pro Tip: Sip It Right

Premium tequilas are best enjoyed:

• Neat or on the rocks (skip the lime & salt)

• In a wide-mouthed glass (like a Glencairn or tumbler)

• Slowly—so you can catch every nuance

Find Your Next Favorite at Payless Liquors

Whether you’re celebrating something big or just want to upgrade your home bar, these premium tequilas are ready and waiting at your local Payless Liquors in Indiana. Shop in-store or browse online to explore our full tequila selection.

Life’s better with better tequila—cheers!